Reasonable on 24 June 2009
I found the article rather perplexing, to be honest. To me the video clearly looked like a mix of pre-rendered (but using engine and game assets) with full gameplay. The shots of the boy on the ledge, in combat with the guards, etc. sure looked like gameplay. The cinematic compositions looked like in-engine cutscenes (just as they used for ICO and SOTC).
Then they make some bold statements, as Slimebeast notes, then in the final paragraph they effectively retract everything with a huge 'but actually we could be completely wrong because we don't actually know what the video contains'.
I'm pretty confident it's gonna be GOTY for me based on what I've seen so far, that's for sure.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
