Reasonable on 21 June 2009
I doubt it will flop. I like the look of it but one thing worries me - feedback. Taken at face value, the no controller stance means no physical feedback.
This seems fun, and it's easy to get all excited about it - but in reality people tend to like physical feedback. It's hardwired into us. I'm concerned that in a truly practical environment this will become a real weak spot.
The Wiimote vibrates, it has sound right in your palm. You feel yourself hit the ball. With Natal (again taking it at face value) you will swing your arm, get zero physical feedback, and only have the same visual feedback you'd also get with the Wii.
I'm really not sure about that aspect.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
