Muramasa: The Demon Blade RPGFan Import review - OUCH

[Khuutra]

zexen_lowe said:

Khuutra said:

Chill, chill.

The thing that I take issue with is the tone of the review, the lack of the reviewer's perspective of the series for which he is reviewing, his stated method of criticism, and the fact that he skipped over how the parts he didn't like are entirely, unquestionably skippable.

Having read it, I still don't see anything wrong with it. His few criticisms look fairly well argumented, as do the good points. That review looks fine to me. I s'pose you as you played the game would notice more things, but as I'm now, that review convinces me

 

Still, I respect RPGFan for having the balls to give some PS2 RPGs the score they deserve, like this one http://www.rpgfan.com/reviews/suikoden5/index.html

They focus on what really matters in an RPG, they give big importance to the story, and they know what RPG gamers look in an RPG

I look at it as a person who is trying to make a living out of criticism, though my experience is primarily literary rather than video game criticism.