Quickdraw McGraw on 12 June 2009
Alan Wake beating out Uncharted 2 in the 'action' category makes no sense. The former isn't even an action title, and doesn't look nearly as impressive as Uncharted 2 regardless (Note: I'm actually heavily interested in Alan Wake, just not as much as Uncharted 
).
Scribblenauts winning Game of the Show is great though. The game is incredibly creative, and looks like a lot of fun to play. It was between that and Uncharted 2 for me personally, so I'm glad one of them took it.
