1up's E3 AWARDS ---- Uncharted 2 WINS Best Of Show!!! (Also ME2 beats FF13)

[Rei]

MontanaHatchet said:

Rei said:

MontanaHatchet said:
Wait, did Rei really just claim that gamers don't believe Uncharted 2 is the game of the show because it doesn't show up the most on a scan of twitter posts and blogs and other internet musings? Am I missing something here?

    Uh oh, I dont think that either 1up or Buzzstudy provide an objective overview on what was the best game of the show. Buzzstudy is closer to reality, however, and that's why I posted it.

It's closer to reality how? The people from 1UP and Buzzstudy probably had hands-on with the games and got to play them. I'd say that's a good opportunity to form an opinion. And you claimed that "gamers" thought differently. But these were really just scans of various places on the internet. And whose to say they thought the games were good? You will find that Natal has the most buzz out of anything in that list, but for all we know, it could just be that 90% of the links are from people who think it looks awful. Let me quote the article itself:

"Oh, and bear this in mind: buzz is buzz. It doesn't differentiate between "good" and "bad", just how often something is discussed. After all, any publicity is good publicity, right?"

   What are you trying to prove here? I said that neither source is objective, have you missed that part?

   What we have here is opinion of five "professional" editors vs. compilation of various internet articles gathered by Buzzstudy. Neither is objective. But out of the two, Buzzstudy is closer to reality.