Based on what I'm looking for, Sony's motion controls seems more fun.

[Zlejedi]

dougsdad0629 said:

I just finished watching the whole Sony E3 press conference and I'm really excited about the potential for the Sony motion controls.  No disrespect to Microsoft and Natal, but for my tastes, Sony's motion control looks more fun.  I think it looks like the perfect middle ground between what the Wii offers and what Microsoft is looking to do with Natal.  I want a controller(s) in my hand(s) while I play and Sony's answer will let me do that.  Sony's motion sensing seems to be the "gamer's" controls whereas Natal is a very "casual" experience.  Again, this is all just based on what I'm personally looking for.

Generally yes but i think best part is with it being optional so you are not forced to use for games where traditional gamepad works better.