makingmusic476 on 05 June 2009
Well, for my personal list, it would be in the top ten with all the 3D Zeldas, LBP, Okami, and the other consoles MGSes. :P
But for a list representing everyone, somewhere in the 40s seems right.
I personally think the list would've looked a lot better if we had allowed 10 games per person instead of just 5. We would've seen a lot more old favorites on lists, rather than just their five most recent favorites. I think that's why we saw so many recent games on the list, like Uncharted. People were like "Wow, this game was awesome," and it pushed older games like Baldur's Gate II, games that truly stand the test of time, further down on people's lists of favorites, not quite making their top 5.
