Media and Press who won E3

[disolitude]

Mr Khan said:

disolitude said:
E3 has become more of a spectacle and less about boring "look at this demo"

Microsofts conference spanked the other 2 in spectacle, and it had enought substance to go toe to toe with both.

Natal left something to the immagination, which is a big plus. Sony's motion controls will be impressive but you know exactly what they can do and how they work, that is boring.

Nintendo on the other hand bored people with "profits" talk...
"Wii sells more 3rd party software" versus Paul Mcartney and Ringo Star? Err...why is anyone even discussing which conference was better?

Well yeah, if we're talking about presentation, then Nintendo is clearly deficient in that regard.

 

I figured that the game media was less shallow than that, though, and would focus on content. Content is how i judge Sony to be narrowly first place, ahead of Nintendo who is roughly equal to Microsoft.

I dont know. To me presentation means a lot for a conference like this, and I don't think im a shallow gamer (whatever that is)

Like Sony looked like they didn't know what thye were doing. Jack Trenton was sweating like crazy, the motion control guys were nervous and shaking, KAz Harai was arrogant and looked like he didnt give a shit...

Nintendo I think had a more composed conference than Sony which was all over the place.

Sony had lots of content, but like I said they screwed up with presentation...For motion controls demo they did, the following analogy works best "if you stick your dick in a pudding, no one is really going to eat it...even if its the best pudding around."