Wii Motion Plus > Sony Purple Wand > Natal

[thx1139]

HappySqurriel said:

bardicverse said:
@thx - depends how you define big. I could say Madworld, but it didnt sell so hot due to the unusual art style. On the horizon is the Conduit, or I could backtrack to COD: WaW. If I wanted to go back more, I can testify to the awesomeness of Bully with motion controls. The only games that don't fit to the motion controls are fighting games, IMO.

You could also include Punch Out!! or Boom Blox which were only released a couple of weeks ago ...

And concensus on Punch Out reviews was that standard controls is the better way to play the game.

 

Now back to the technology topic. Another reason that Natal will provide the superior choice is that it is full motion recognition. While Wii and Sony control are really just arm movements.  The demo of Ricochet showed full body motion control not just what you are holding in your hands or secondary WiiBoard if you have it. Also adding WiiBoard makes it so you are forced to stay on the board.  Sony doesnt even offer a way to control the movement of the player let alone track any movements other than the controller.