I think MS won it by a large margin because of Project Natal, Milo, MGS, Left 4 Dead 2, Facebook / Twitter, and the Netflix improvements. They also announced actual firm release dates for many titles we already knew about like H3: ODST, Forza 3 (which looked amazing), L4D2. They also showed some stuff for not so distant future like Alan Wake and Halo Reach.
Sony also had a great show especially when it comes to the PSP. Even though I do not like Sony consoles I was very impressed with their lineups for both PS3 and PSP. In fact I liked what they showed for the PSP so much that I am seriously considering trading in my DS and all my games for a PSP 3000. On the PS3 side they showed footage again of a game called Last Guardian and it is absolutely stunning. Sony would have gotten higher marks had it not been for the leaks, and by the way PSP Go is pretty cool but Waaay over priced, At most should cost same price as DSI.
Nintendo wasn't even in the same ballpark as Sony or Microsoft. Their conference was a complete snoozer and turned into an utter embarrassment with the Vitality monitor. They saved it from utter chaos during the last 10 minutes. Dead Space caught my interest as did Mario Galaxy 2 and Metroid M, but both of them looked to be at least a full year from release. They showed Conduit and it will be out this fall but it is a lesser game against ODST, L4D2, Modern Warfare 2, Bioshock 2, Uncharted 2, and other shooters. The Resident Evil game just looked average at best, another real disappointment. And it is now official the DS is now lame as it is now a handheld aimed primarily at little girls.
