Reasonable on 03 June 2009
On personal taste I found it to be Sony, followed by MS then Nintendo with almost nothing to separate them.
The Last Guardian and Uncharted 2 were for me far and away the best titles shown hence my personal preference. While it was super professional and Natal was interesting there was not one surprise nor great new title announced for MS from my point of view. Nintendo announced a lot of new titles but few appealed to me (I'm not a big Nintendo gamer, Mario fan coming from PC roots).
All 3 were professional and good though, so overall I think it was near enough a tie if you remove personal preference.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
