PS3 officially GRAPHICS KING!!!!!!

[TheSteve]

Munkeh111 said:

Showertea said:
Why this thread is dumb:

It's impossible for any device to be 'officially' best in graphics, because there's no officiating body. There's no Graphics Court that will say 'The PS3 is the best, that is our official verdict'. It's just a ton of fanboys, all clamoring and shouting at one another.

In some way you can by doing a technical analysis, but that ignores art style and animation

Good post...  That was my take.  You can "prove" that something is technically superior with polygon count and stuff, but even then it can subjectively look like crap if the style and execution is lacking, or just not to your liking.  SFIV, for instance, has left a lot of people cold, despite its technical merits in its graphics.  KZ2 is similar, as there are complaints about about "drab" level design, "cookie cutter" enemies, and "bad" facial animation.  The OP cited Gears of War 2 as the "height" of 360's animation prowess, but you're presented with similar "drab" color pallette, "roided out" style...  There's no way to nail something as "best".