I think the Wii remote is still superior.
Firstly, Natal doesn't give the user any haptic or tactile feedback. The great thing about the Wii remote is that you can grasp it to mimic a tennis racket, sword, golf club etc. and receive rumble feedback with impact. Playing Mario Kart with the Wii wheel wasn't flawless because there was no resistance but at least you had something to grasp on.
Secondly, unless I am wrong, you can't have any pointer reticule on screen using Natal. Pointer controls were awesome in games like RE 4, RE: UC, Elebits, Metroid Prime 3, World of Goo.
Lastly, there are no buttons. Unless I like imagination, how in the world are you expect to play a platformer or FPS game using Natal?
I think stuff like this will work great for some games such as a Wario Ware type games and exer-games but it can't touch the Wii remote when it comes to sheer versatility. The Wii remote can be more applicative to different genres of video games than Natal. But I could be wrong.







