My Halo 3 (360) review

[Lost tears of Kain]

naznatips said:
LtoK, no one can rate SMG. It's not out yet. However, if you are trying to use it as an example of a great game that doesn't change anything from it's predecessors you probably should look elsewhere. By adding varrying degrees of gravity on every part of the game SMG has completely changed the core platforming gameplay. What defines a platformer is consistent abilities used in perfect timing. SMG is shaking taking that and bitchslapping it. As I have said many times, Halo 3 is very fun. What has it changed in the shooter genre though?

again it seems its just polishing and adding things to the original 64 game. It still is the same old game, but adding gravity, thats no different then adding guns that have never been seen before, or such a unique theater as well. It still comes down to the fact that both are the same game, should they be dealt a bigger blow because they are not completely new, and thats what im saying. The answer in my mind is of course no Both SMG and Halo in my mind are GOTY material, yet ive seen people say "well its to much like halo 2" same could be said of SMG, so should it be dealt the same consequences. It will most likely not on this site because of the huge pro nintendo on this site. Both are good games, and neither should be dealt a blow in their review score because they are not completely new, instead mention how its more like a good polished Halo 2 that adds stuff, but is not completely different.