JMan on 08 October 2007
It really depends on the game. I don't want to see a real live Mario. I prefer him without the plumber's butt crack 
I do like being more involved in the video game, but I wouldn't want "realistic" motion controls for a SSBB type game, where I had to do my own backflips and stuff. I think semirealistic motion controls are good, and I think realistic looking games where realism enhances the game is good. More of the games I like deal with semirealistic motion, so for me, MC > G
