Gamer Intuition. After first 5 min are you able to say if it's good or not?

[GamingChartzFTW]

Experienced gamers are able to do it! Only 5 min of gameplay is needed and you instantly know if the game is a 'Quality production', mediocre or a piece of crap.

If you have this ability, then what is the first thing you notice when playing..

1. A game with high production values (Quality Game)?
2. A game with 'medium' production values (Mediocre Game)?
3. A game with low production values (Crappy Game)?

Feel free to elaborate