I always exclude comedy shows from my list, as they are all funny (30 Rock, Family Guy, Aqua Teen Hunger Force, American Dad, South Park, etc, etc)
So my list would be:
1. Smallville (As gay as it is sometimes...No one can top the Finale/Premieres of Smallville
2. Lost (Having a Lost party on Wednesday... Home-made Dharma drinks, bages, jumpsuits, etc!)
and tied for 3rd is
3. 24 (Though the later seasons aren't as good, but used to be my favorite)
3. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles (Shame it didnt get renewed)
Battlestar Galactica used to be good, but they kind of ruined it for me
Prison Break used to be good, but lacked in every department in the 2nd season+







