Having played both I'm going to say I enjoyed SotC more than Zelda: TP. SotC is repetitive in its gameplay as in the only thing you're doing is killing the Colossi with nothing in between but a bunch of running around. The Colossi however all present different challenges really mixing up the gameplay.
Zelda provides a ton of variety with different items and unique bosses and caves but it just didn't click with me. I think I got annoyed with the lack of proper voice overs (read: annoying sounds for voices... and those friggen monkeys near the beginning. argh!).
Both are great but I'd have to give the nod to SotC. It truly is something different and should be experienced by everyone. Love the music and atmosphere like many others have mentioned.







