Halo 3 or Metal Gear Solid 4. Which is the greatest/most influential game.

[rocketpig]

goddog said:

rocketpig said:
I view this akin to arguing over whether Return of the Jedi was better than The Godfather 3.

One had muppets, the other Sophia Coppola.

In the end, both series had far better offerings previous to these latest games.

 

I have to go with rocket pig here ... the more I play halo 3 the more it makes me pine for halo 1 story and halo 2 online... the extra features in 3 keep it alive.....  MGS4 it looks pretty and makes a nice interactive movie, but needs an editor and to stick to the series core in mechanics .... 

Exactly how I feel. Halo 1 had a fun story, Halo 2 had the online play (though DAMN BUNGIE for not sticking with the assault rifle). MGS had the story and "newness" while MGS3 had the multitude of options (though damn that camera and those horrid controls).

MGS2 was rubbish.

Halo 3 and MGS4 are excellent examples of moving the series forward technically to the tune of losing some of the magic that made them so much fun in the first place.