If I were a Palestinian...

[Kasz216]

ManusJustus said:

Kasz216 said:

ManusJustus said:

Its a very bad argument then, for the reasons mentioned above.

Are you American?  If so, where will you be going when we give the Native Americans all their land back?

I don't.... get your argument.  Wouldn't that be a pro-Israel argument?  Afterall... what the UN and UK did was basically similar.  Except they put the jews there insead of stayed themselves.

It would of been as if the US conquered Peru and said "Whoops sorry Native Americans..  You can live here now."

Palestinians were living in Palestine for millenia, and then israel claimed that the land belonged to them because they lived there a long time ago.

By the same logic, even though European Americans have been living in America for centuries, the right thing to do would be to take land from European Americans, give it to Native Americans, and force Europeans out of the country.

So how much time must pass then before it's suddenly "Ok".

After all the Jews have been there for over a half centurty and had to endure quite a bit.

If Israel stalls another 150 years it's ok? 

There is little difference between US and Israel in that regard.  Outside the comparisons that favor israel.

It was the International community and not themeselves who gave Israel that land, and unlike the US who attacked first... Israel wasn't the agressor in there war for land.

Your argument's logic doesn't match your position.

Those who support Palestine should also be for the Native Americans getting back their lands... etc.