By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Viper1 said:

It opens the doors for further conscriptions, civil service duty, etc...

 

Actually, it doesn't. You may or may not have noticed, but Gordon Brown won't do this without putting it in a manifesto and putting it through election first.

That's simply because Parliament will not let the Government get a bill through without a mandate. You can only have a mandate if there's an overwhelming public outcry (read: Dangerous Dogs Act, Hunting with Dogs Act, and whatever Act it was that put on scriter gun control), a referendum on the matter, or if it was in the party's manifesto leading up to election.

A good example of Parliament putting a stop to something that the Government wanted without mandate was the 42-Days Bill that they tried to push through last year.

Of course, this isn't a written rule, merely a convention - but conventions hold an amazing amount of power in the British constitution.

---

One other point: The Labour party, since its election in 1997, has sought to increase democracy in the UK, and Gordon Brown in particular has passed a few Acts to increase democracy in the UK, the Supreme Court Act, for example, abolished the Law Lords and has finally seperated the Judiciary and Legislature - something that the Americans have been doing since the birth of their constitution.