I would give it a 8.
graphics - Amazing
Story - Decent but I found the dreams the best and very touching. Stories like little Liar really made me feel soft, they are even so great I want to buy the book of it and oh, I can't forget how bad disc three was X_X! I almost quit the game.
Music - Excellent can't complain about it.
Gameplay - For a lot of JRPG fans it probably feels alright but for me it was kind to slow, like Montana mentioned the loading times are a pain in the ass and I HATE THE LEVELING UP system. I encourage devs/producers who try to make JRPG's different but this was one I wished they didn't changed.
Overall the game was better than I expected but it had some flaws I can't forgive.