By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
BengaBenga said:

Yes, it is. if it doesn't actually adds something to the site.

But this is a member that is on VGC for quite some time and is a respected one as well. I don't want people spamming the site with loads of threads about every other blog, but a relevant thread from a respected member is fine with me.

I don't see another "Top X" list as adding anything.  Digg and Reddit are filled with them and another 3 seem to come out weekly.  To me a "Top X" list shows a lack of creativity and only serves to generate website hits.  Sometimes I think that's how IGN and the rest fill out their "slow" weeks.  YMMV.

I also don't like the "respected member" bit.  One member shouldn't have more privileges than another and that's exactly what you're suggesting there.