I don't see what's wrong with it... it's nothing amazing... but then I have seen very few boxarts of any games I consider better than average.
It's one of the things gaming hasn't done right yet.... there are many great book covers, album covers, and to a lesser extent DVD covers, but only a minute percentage of game covers are more than "decent".
All I ask of a cover at the moment is to get the job done in terms of appeal... and this does that IMO.... (whether it is the real one or not) this is a good cover for getting people interested in the game if they haven't previously heard of it (ie the "masses" who don't frequent websites like this)
If it had what some of you are asking, something simple perhaps with not much on it to explain the content of the game, then perhaps it would please the few people who value things like that somewhat, but then if the cover doesn't tell the rest of the gaming masses what the game involves, they might not buy it.
