Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Super Mario Galaxy. Which is the Greatest??

[--OkeyDokey--]

dahuman said:

--OkeyDokey-- said:
My two favourite games this gen ;_;

Both of them blew me away the first time round.
Galaxy kind of lost its magic by the third playthrough but I've only played MGS4 once (waiting for trophies >_>), so I'm still stuck with my first impression on that one.

For that reason I say MGS4, but it's close...

 

dood, you played through SMG 3 times without trophies and MGS4 once without trophies and you are telling me you like MGS4 better? =P

I only played SMG 3 times because (at the time) all I had was a Wii and there was nothing else to play on it :P