BxN on 29 March 2009
I'm going to say Bioshock 2, or maybe God of War if it manages to come out this year (I don't think this game will suffer the same faith as DMC and Ninja Gaiden since GOW has always more acclaimed and just plain better than the last two).
edit:
Why are you all answering GTA: CW ? Street Fighter 4 has the exact same score, so it should definitely be a tie.
