well don't really have any total shitfests, but out of all the games I own and or rented the ones i hated the most were FF3, and FF7 and possibly GTA San Andreas. Sure I got really far in both 3 and GTA and had fun for a while, but then the novelty wore off for GTA and realized it was same old thing and no longer having fun (would never play again ever), and for FF3 just didn't really ever get into the story. FF7 i did finish but really just didn't think was that great and wondered why even finished, must have been at a game drought time and had not much going on in activities in real life
and since this question is the FIRST game, i played FF7 before the other two so the answer is
FF7







