UMD a waste of time and money, says Dave Perry

[shams]

http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?aid=28697

PSP Slim and Lite remodel a "head in the sand" move

The UMD is a dead format that's a waste of money, time, and investment according to David Perry.

Speaking to GamesIndustry.biz, the Shiny founder and operator of GameConsultants.com revealed what he would do if he were in charge of PlayStation Portable development.

"They really need to restart the PSP programme in my book. They really need to bring out the PSP 3.0 and start again and try to get a lot of units out by reducing the manufacturing costs, by taking out all the motors and drives and stuff they have in there."

"That will make it even more sexy-looking, because it will be thinner again when they get all that junk out. Then, hopefully, the platform will actually get enough interest so that people will make a game specifically for it," Perry said.

He referred to the recent PSP Slim and Lite remodel as a "head in the sand" move.

As for what current PSP owners will do with their UMDs if Sony turns to a download-only handheld, Perry said that it would be fairly trivial to include software to validate that a user owns a certain game, much like iTunes. With authentication, users should be allowed to download digital versions of UMD games they already own.

When questioned as to why Sony hadn't already done this, Perry responded: "The truth is, the stores will not carry PSPs unless they feel they are going to get a piece of the action on the back end. And Sony has not come up with an innovative business model that can support that concept."

But with the industry moving in the direction of digital downloads, Sony needs to come up with a shared revenue system eventually.

"Maybe its an even slightly better deal because there is no cost of goods, and shipping, insurance, and warehousing is all out the window...so maybe the store gets a little bit more. And they get more of their shelf space back, which is their most valuable asset."

The complete interview with Dave Perry will be published tomorrow on GamesIndustry.biz.

I don't agree with a lot that Dave Perry says, but I agree with this (as I think a lot of people would as well).

Again, it all comes back to Sony's obsession with optical media. The DS >> PSP, purely because of carts vrs discs (I could refer back to an old thread about this).

Sony does have a few issues though. The excessively large size of disc-based content, makes it unpractical (or less practical) for use with digital distribution. It also means the device needs a heap of onboard RAM/Flash RAM (USB based?).

We'll see how the PSPslim does, but I genuinely believe that Sony *must* release the PSP II before the DS II if they want a chance in the next phase of the handheld wars.