By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
vlad321 said:

I will ask you again, does the US, or any other country in this category, count itself as part of the West suffer from the possibility of such a regime? Or even more interestingly, if such a thing were to happen, are you telling me you, our buddies,  and your handguns would be able to deter the army?

Yes, I think the West can easily suffer from an authoritarian regime if we allow ourselves to dive into such. In any Democracy, we allow ourselves to vote on our next leader. If the leader is bad, and has bad motives behind their candidacy as leader, things can happen. What about Chavez? Putin? Both were democratically elected, but have projected their powers into a far different sphere. Yes, in typical Western countries it would be difficult, but not impossible. Hitler did it, after all, and caused 100 million deaths. I tend to think that the 12,000 deaths due to handguns in the US per year is a small price to pay to prevent the atrocities committed by horrible regimes.

And yes, having an armed militia could deterr even a great army such as the US Army, or any others. Just look at Iraq for proof. The uprising there has hampered military efforts in the region thanks to a few ten thousand insurgents. If such a regime took place in the US, the insurgency would be in the millions, if not tens of millions. When you have numbers like that on your side, it would be very difficult for any army, no matter how competent, to wage a guerilla style war against an insurgent force 10-20x your armies size.



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.