Reasonable on 08 March 2009
Given neither game is released this is impossible to answer right now. Although I see snippet videos, screenshots, etc. aren't stopping people.
Well, just remember that the trailer for the first Star Wars prequel is judged one of the best ever, and convinced a whole bucket load of people the film was going to deliver in spades - and look how that turned out!
You simply can't judge a game from the information currently available for these two at this moment.
You can argue which one has been better marketed so far, though, and has gained the best recognition at this point - so why not do that instead?
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
