By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
scottie said:
I find this to be an invalid comparison.

Your argument runs

If a dev puts effort into making a 2d game look good, then it will look better than a 3d game with no effort put it.

A valid comparison would be to see which looks better out of

A shit 2d game and a shit 3d game

as well as a good 2d game and a good 3d game.

3d will win in both cases

Aww, you don't really believe that, do you?

I'm pretty sure all the ugliest games in the world are 3D.  3D has a much lower rock bottom of ugliness than 2D does.  When 2D goes wrong, it's just ugly shapes and sprites.  When 3D goes wrong, it's a whole world of ugliness that makes me want to puke.