windbane said:
Yeah, Sony did/does all of that. Failed formats aren't punishing the consumer. If enough people suffered and bought into it, it would have succeeded. That's bad for Sony; I'm sure they didn't create the format with the intention of it failing. As for DRM, well, movies companies never try that. Other Audio companies never try DRM. DRM may be a waste of time and it'll be better when they realize that fact, but attempting DRM prevents people from copying and they make more money. Now, the main response I have is very simple: don't act like Nintendo and ESPECIALLY Microsoft are innocent. How many broken promises have been made by both companies? Microsoft created Windows by screwing over the guy that made DOS, so the whole company is founded on questionable morales. Microsoft is not exactly known for their trustfulness. That's a nice list you created, but you could create a longer list of DRM and other issues with Microsoft. I suppose you just don't buy consoles because no console manufactorer can be trusted. |
First about the failed formats, I know SONY didn't make it fail on purpose, however, it still makes it difficult to trust them. They basically crippled every format they tried to push by closing it up and making it unusable.
Secondly, on DRM, "other people do it so it excuses me" is no excuse. More and more music executives are realising that DRM is losing them money and hopefully Apple's recent move to provide some tracks without DRM will convince more people that it's a waste of money and no one want it. SONY, however, is a major pusher of DRM (just look at the rootkit fiasco, which I noticed you didn't try to respond to)
I never said anything about Nintendo and Microsoft. I was stating why SONY shouldn't be trusted. I agree that all three of the big three are untrustworthy, to differing amounts. Now, I refuse to buy any SONY products at all, and I try my best to avoid MS but it's quite difficult to do. I'm sure I could create a much larger list on Microsoft but that wasn't the point ;) As for Nintendo, yes, they have done a lot of things that I think are terrible practises but nothing compared to the other two.
In summary, I wasn't advocating never purchasing a product from a company that ever does anything single thing wrong. But SONY and yes, Microsoft are definitely not to be trusted.
Help! I'm stuck in a forum signature!