I think the best controller is the Wiimote. It just feels right, and felt right the minute i first toughed it. I also love having my two hand separated.
I do think the nunchunck could be better. I believe the C and Z buttons should have been moved slightly to the right so that they could be tapped with the tips of your fingers, and i would have made changes to the analogue stick as it can get quite uncomfortable after long hours. I would also attach Wii motion plus to the thing. I.e. Nintendo really needs to come out with a new nunchuck.
I never got into any controller with two analogue sticks. I just don't have the level of orientation to cope, which is why i abandoned the gaming community for a couple of generations.
Ps. The DS controls are simply brilliant and i do not understand why no publisher has tried to incorporate DS controls into a Wii game.
Member of the Pikmin Fan Club







