Best and Worst controller design

[twesterm]

soccerdrew17 said:

*no one here has stated anything that comes close to the worst controller. atari anyone?

as far as best: m&k for precision games (fps, rts), gc for smash bros, ds for everything else

 

*at time of original intent

 

Which Atari controller are you talking about?  The 2600 one was good, the 5200 not so much but still wouldn't be the worst (assuming yours works).