If Watchmen shouldn't be a brawler, what should it be?

[Bursche]

Have it as a pseudo- point and click adventure. You are Rorschach (sp?) and you have to investigate everything like in the graphic novel. The style would be comic oriented, with amazing graphics and visuals, with really humorous text. That's the only way you can stay true to the novel part of Watchmen, and not so much as the super hero part, because honestly there was barely any action in the novel to justify a brawler.