Final-Fan said:
kn said:
Actually, this thread, as with the other, is filled with complete misinformation. Interlace "flicker" is a function of CRT displays, NOT LCD or Plasma. Why do people who know nothing about the technology feel compelled to give advice when it is so wrong?
LCD and Plasma inherently display ONLY progressive images -- in other words, they MUST de-interlace every image they display -- each and every frame. That means that it boils down to the source frame rate. Go do some research... There is so much mis-information from every person out there that doesn't know what he is talking about that it truly is confusing.
At 30FPS or less, 1080i is going to beat 720P on an LCD or Plasma as the image is de-interlaced anyway. At framerates greater than 30fps, the de-interlacer for the 1080i image is going to have to do some "interpolation" when displaying. This cause some loss of image quality. As to your original question: For Movies: 1080i = 1080p. Movies are encoded at 24FPS. No difference as long as your set de-interlaces properly. For ESPN HD: 720P is probably going to look better but it is going to depend on the broadcast source. Some say 1080i looks better "over the air". I don't think you will see much difference if the broadcast is a quality feed. And finally, for games : For every game that is 60fps, 720P will rock. It will keep up with the fast moving objects. |
If it automatically deinterlaces then what is the penalty? It obviously doesn't magically turn into 1080p. Does it turn into 1080p with half the framerate?
I appreciate that you are trying to correct misinformation, but you mostly seem to be saying that the previous explanation is wrong without offering the correct one (although you do explain which one of 1080i/720p is better in your opinion and why). |
1080i draws 2 parts of the same frame in seperate batches and ghosting does occur because in order to de interlace an image it has to reconstruct the full frame. The problem with this is is that films are played back at 24 fps and 1080i is at 30 fps(60 per field). the process is called a 3:2 pull down and is used for both the ATSC and NTSC standards. In tubes you get flicker because tubes were original designed to skip one line of pixels to allow for the phosphates to cool down after being excited. It isn't as bad on an HDTV since it does still fill the screen and the increased resolution helps to hide some of the adverse effects. Wikipedia has some great examples of the negative effects that can occur when using interlacing or just converting a film with 24fps to 30 fps(reverse telecine[a relecine converts film to other formats like digital, Dat, VHS what not]). The image will be ghosted and with 1080i it is more apparant. For me I would use720P or 1080P but honestly most people wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
