I genuinely have the opposite opinion then you and I (as in self, not neighbor) actually own both. Furthermore, Gears 2 is by far the best looking game on 360 and while gritty it certainly doesn't look realistic. As far as realism, I would give that title to Uncharted. Uncharted, MGS4 and Killzone 2 are all amazing games, I'd go as far as saying that they are the three best looking games on consoles and they all have a grit to them. Many complaints to Killzone 2 is that it's a gritty game. In Uncharted, dispite the jungle setting, Nathan Drake is very dirty and you can see the stains and dirty on his clothes and skin. In MGS4, while not as gritty as most, it still is fairly gritty. It certainly isn't clean. As explosions go off the screen itself will become covered in dust and dirt.









