Is Dead Space really the scariest game of all time?

[tehsage]

bbsin said:

No, Deadspace is not scary. The main character is far too powerful for the game to be considered scary.

Isaac can pistol whip and stomp his enemy's limbs off for Christ's sake, how is that considered scary?

In order for a game to be scary there should be several things present.
1. Crappy controls (so it's hard to turn around and run away)
2. A weak main character
3. Few weapons and bullets along with very little health.

 

Jill from REmake?