Reviews - Should Graphics Effect The Score?

[Bodhesatva]

Fumanchu said:

Most Definitely. Why should the efforts of the art department who sweat blood trying to push the boundaries of the hardware capabilities go undermined? Wouldn't it be considered somewhat counter-progressive to ignore their feats?

Yes they should 'Affect' the score but not at the expense of overlooking good gameplay. That's why they each have their own distinct categories to be passed judgement on, which affect the overall score.

 

Why don't movie critics give extra scores for a movie having awesome special effects? That's where most of the money is spent on those big budget blockbuster movies.

Answer: because CGI/Special effects are a superficial and superfluous concern. Film (and flim critics) have grown up. When will gaming? Will it ever?