Sorry but I completely disagree with your SMG assessment. A GoTY should be fun for a large group of people, and a game like Bioshock just isn't fun to a very large segment of the gaming public. SMG hits that standard and it hits it hard.
Seriously if fun isn't the benchmark then why are you gaming?
Edit: PS - I think Crysis is going to be better than Bioshock on probably all counts except music/sound, and you haven't even mentioned the game, so I am kind of interested to hear your assessment of it and the reasons its not included.








