What's going to be G.O.T.Y?

[ckmlb]

twesterm said:

Halo 3 won't make it because, well, why would it make it? Just because a game is insanely popular doesn't make it the best game of the year. It really hasn't done much new and it's only Halo. I know people are going to jump on me for saying this, but Halo 3 will not be on the Game of the Year list. I'm not saying it's bad, it's just not the best.

If Halo 3 isn't doing much new then neither is Mario Galaxy, it's still the same old Mario 64 with better graphics and set in space. Which already makes it a great game and returns Mario to quality after the Mario Sunshine debacle. Will be a great game, but not Game of the Year material.