mrstickball on 27 January 2009
I think we're missing how to properly look at the data. If you look close enough, the PS3 has more exclusives:
First, we take Onyx's list:
90+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Halo 3 | LittleBigPlanet | |
| Gears of War 2 | Metal Gear Solid 4 | |
| Forza Motorsport 2 | ||
| Total=3 | Total=2 |
80+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Fable II | Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction |
|
| Project Gotham Racing 3 | Uncharted: Drake's Fortune | |
| Dead or Alive 4 | Valkyria Chronicles | |
| Dead Rising | Resistance 2 | |
| Project Gotham Racing 4 | Resistance: Fall of Man | |
| Crackdown | Warhawk | |
| Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise | Motorstorm | |
| Saints Row | SingStar | |
| Perfect Dark Zero | Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds | |
| Ninja Gaiden II | Motorstorm: Pacific Rift | |
| Tales of Vesperia | Gran Turismo 5: Prologue | |
| Moto GP 06 | Buzz! Quiz TV | |
| Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation | ||
| Naruto: The Broken Bond | ||
| Total=14 | Total=12 | |
70+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Kameo: Elements of Power | Heavenly Sword | |
| Blue Dragon | Ridge Racer 7 | |
| Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts | Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice | |
| Naruto: Rise of a Ninja | SingStar Vol. 2 | |
| Lost Odyssey | The Eye of Judgement | |
| Culdcept Saga | Folklore | |
| Scene It! Box Office Smash | Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm | |
| Ridge Racer 6 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe | ||
| Beautiful Katamari | ||
| Scene It! Lights, Camera, Action | ||
| Amped 3 | ||
| Chromehounds | ||
| Lips | ||
| Full Auto | ||
| The Outfit | ||
| Total=16 | Total=7 | |
60+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Earth Defense Force 2017 | SingStar Vol. 3 | |
| Namco Museum: Virtual Arcade | SOCOM: Confrontation | |
| Infinite Undiscovery | Time Crisis 4 | |
| Too Human | ||
| The Last Remnant | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 2 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 3 | ||
| Project Sylpheed: Arc of Deception | ||
| Rumble Roses XX | ||
| Ninety-Nine Nights | ||
| Total=10 | Total=3 | |
50+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| WarTech: Senko no Ronde | Untold Legends: Dark Kingdom | |
| Spectral Force 3 | Genji: Days of the Blade | |
| Tenchu Z | Haze | |
| Viva Pinata: Party Animals | Lair | |
| Guilty Gear 2: Overture | ||
| Deadliest Catch: Alaskan Storm | ||
| Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom | ||
| You're In the Movies | ||
| Bullet Witch | ||
| Dead or Alive Xtreme 2 | ||
| Tetris Evolution | ||
| Total=11 | Total=4 | |
49 and Below Metacritic(Shovelware)
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Over G Fighters | Mobile Suit Gundam: Crossfire | |
| Fuzion Frenzy 2 | ||
| Operation Darkness | ||
| Zoids Assault | ||
| America's Army: True Soldiers | ||
| Kengo: Legend of the 9 | ||
| Destroy All Humans: Path of the Furon | ||
| Bomberman: Act Zero | ||
| Total=8 | Total=1 | |
What's the first thing on the list you notice? Shooters. There's just too many of them. No one likes shooters, since they're all better on PC.
So let's re-do this:
90+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| LittleBigPlanet | ||
| Metal Gear Solid 4 | ||
| Forza Motorsport 2 | ||
| Total=1 | Total=2 |
80+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Fable II | Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction |
|
| Project Gotham Racing 3 | Uncharted: Drake's Fortune | |
| Dead or Alive 4 | Valkyria Chronicles | |
| Dead Rising | ||
| Project Gotham Racing 4 | ||
| Warhawk | ||
| Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise | Motorstorm | |
| Saints Row | SingStar | |
| Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds | ||
| Ninja Gaiden II | Motorstorm: Pacific Rift | |
| Tales of Vesperia | Gran Turismo 5: Prologue | |
| Moto GP 06 | Buzz! Quiz TV | |
| Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation | ||
| Naruto: The Broken Bond | ||
| Total=12 | Total=12 | |
70+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Kameo: Elements of Power | Heavenly Sword | |
| Blue Dragon | Ridge Racer 7 | |
| Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts | Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice | |
| Naruto: Rise of a Ninja | SingStar Vol. 2 | |
| Lost Odyssey | The Eye of Judgement | |
| Culdcept Saga | Folklore | |
| Scene It! Box Office Smash | Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm | |
| Ridge Racer 6 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe | ||
| Beautiful Katamari | ||
| Scene It! Lights, Camera, Action | ||
| Amped 3 | ||
| Chromehounds | ||
| Lips | ||
| Full Auto | ||
| Total=15 | Total=7 | |
60+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| SingStar Vol. 3 | ||
| Namco Museum: Virtual Arcade | ||
| Infinite Undiscovery | Time Crisis 4 | |
| Too Human | ||
| The Last Remnant | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 2 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 3 | ||
| Project Sylpheed: Arc of Deception | ||
| Rumble Roses XX | ||
| Ninety-Nine Nights | ||
| Total=9 | Total=2 | |
50+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Untold Legends: Dark Kingdom | ||
| Spectral Force 3 | Genji: Days of the Blade | |
| Tenchu Z | Haze | |
| Viva Pinata: Party Animals | Lair | |
| Guilty Gear 2: Overture | ||
| Deadliest Catch: Alaskan Storm | ||
| Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom | ||
| You're In the Movies | ||
| Dead or Alive Xtreme 2 | ||
| Tetris Evolution | ||
| Total=9 | Total=4 | |
49 and Below Metacritic(Shovelware)
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Over G Fighters | Mobile Suit Gundam: Crossfire | |
| Fuzion Frenzy 2 | ||
| Zoids Assault | ||
| America's Army: True Soldiers | ||
| Kengo: Legend of the 9 | ||
| Destroy All Humans: Path of the Furon | ||
| Bomberman: Act Zero | ||
| Total=8 | Total=1 | |
Next, we strip out RPGs since they're a dying breed that have been console-ized, and are pretty useless in shio's eyes:
90+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| LittleBigPlanet | ||
| Metal Gear Solid 4 | ||
| Forza Motorsport 2 | ||
| Total=1 | Total=2 |
80+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction |
||
| Project Gotham Racing 3 | Uncharted: Drake's Fortune | |
| Dead or Alive 4 | Valkyria Chronicles | |
| Dead Rising | ||
| Project Gotham Racing 4 | ||
| Warhawk | ||
| Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise | Motorstorm | |
| Saints Row | SingStar | |
| Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds | ||
| Ninja Gaiden II | Motorstorm: Pacific Rift | |
| Gran Turismo 5: Prologue | ||
| Moto GP 06 | Buzz! Quiz TV | |
| Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation | ||
| Naruto: The Broken Bond | ||
| Total=10 | Total=12 | |
70+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Kameo: Elements of Power | Heavenly Sword | |
| Ridge Racer 7 | ||
| Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts | Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice | |
| Naruto: Rise of a Ninja | SingStar Vol. 2 | |
| The Eye of Judgement | ||
| Folklore | ||
| Scene It! Box Office Smash | Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm | |
| Ridge Racer 6 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe | ||
| Beautiful Katamari | ||
| Scene It! Lights, Camera, Action | ||
| Amped 3 | ||
| Chromehounds | ||
| Lips | ||
| Full Auto | ||
| Total=13 | Total=7 | |
60+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| SingStar Vol. 3 | ||
| Namco Museum: Virtual Arcade | ||
| Time Crisis 4 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 2 | ||
| Dance Dance Revolution Universe 3 | ||
| Project Sylpheed: Arc of Deception | ||
| Rumble Roses XX | ||
| Ninety-Nine Nights | ||
| Total=6 | Total=2 | |
50+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Untold Legends: Dark Kingdom | ||
| Genji: Days of the Blade | ||
| Tenchu Z | Haze | |
| Viva Pinata: Party Animals | Lair | |
| Deadliest Catch: Alaskan Storm | ||
| You're In the Movies | ||
| Dead or Alive Xtreme 2 | ||
| Tetris Evolution | ||
| Total=6 | Total=4 | |
49 and Below Metacritic(Shovelware)
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Over G Fighters | Mobile Suit Gundam: Crossfire | |
| Fuzion Frenzy 2 | ||
| America's Army: True Soldiers | ||
| Kengo: Legend of the 9 | ||
| Destroy All Humans: Path of the Furon | ||
| Bomberman: Act Zero | ||
| Total=8 | Total=1 | |
Now for the final act. D stands for 'dumb', so lets remove all the titles that start with the letter D:
90+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| LittleBigPlanet | ||
| Metal Gear Solid 4 | ||
| Forza Motorsport 2 | ||
| Total=1 | Total=2 |
80+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction |
||
| Project Gotham Racing 3 | Uncharted: Drake's Fortune | |
| Valkyria Chronicles | ||
| Project Gotham Racing 4 | ||
| Warhawk | ||
| Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise | Motorstorm | |
| Saints Row | SingStar | |
| Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds | ||
| Ninja Gaiden II | Motorstorm: Pacific Rift | |
| Gran Turismo 5: Prologue | ||
| Moto GP 06 | Buzz! Quiz TV | |
| Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation | ||
| Naruto: The Broken Bond | ||
| Total=8 | Total=12 | |
70+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Kameo: Elements of Power | Heavenly Sword | |
| Ridge Racer 7 | ||
| Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts | ||
| Naruto: Rise of a Ninja | SingStar Vol. 2 | |
| The Eye of Judgement | ||
| Scene It! Box Office Smash | Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm | |
| Ridge Racer 6 | ||
| Beautiful Katamari | ||
| Scene It! Lights, Camera, Action | ||
| Amped 3 | ||
| Chromehounds | ||
| Lips | ||
| Full Auto | ||
| Total=11 | Total=5 | |
60+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| SingStar Vol. 3 | ||
| Namco Museum: Virtual Arcade | ||
| Time Crisis 4 | ||
| Project Sylpheed: Arc of Deception | ||
| Rumble Roses XX | ||
| Ninety-Nine Nights | ||
| Total=4 | Total=2 | |
50+ Metacritic
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Untold Legends: Dark Kingdom | ||
| Genji: Days of the Blade | ||
| Tenchu Z | Haze | |
| Viva Pinata: Party Animals | Lair | |
| You're In the Movies | ||
| Tetris Evolution | ||
| Total=4 | Total=4 | |
49 and Below Metacritic(Shovelware)
| 360 | PS3 | |
| Over G Fighters | Mobile Suit Gundam: Crossfire | |
| Fuzion Frenzy 2 | ||
| America's Army: True Soldiers | ||
| Kengo: Legend of the 9 | ||
| Bomberman: Act Zero | ||
| Total=7 | Total=1 | |
The total count for this totally un-biased look? X360 with a paltry 33 exclusives, and the Playstation 3 with a masterful 27 games, and a huge lead for games above 80 Metacritic.
See Onyx how wrong you were? This is the only way to look at exclusives. It certainly points in the PS3's favor, so it must be true!
Back from the dead, I'm afraid.
