Who has the best fall lineup? Category=RPG

[Kasz216]

ssj12 said:

naznatips said:

thors1982 said:
Puzzle Quest is comming to XBLA, should be within a month or so, I thuoght they said September

First time ever, I agree with Leo-j.... I think Folklore should be on that list... However NO to the rest :-p
either that or remove "Eye of Judgement" and "Puzzle Quest" those two games are not RPG's in my opinion. I would say your "sub-genre" is VERY MUCH their primary.

Also, why not Blue Dragon and Two Worlds, id consider August 24th and 28th a fall title..

Great post though

I agree about Puzzle Quest. It should be on the 360 list as an XBLA title.

Folklore isn't listed as an RPG anywhere. Examples:

Wikipedia: Action Adventure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folklore_%28video_game%29

Gamespot: Fantasy Action Adventure http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/rpg/monstercarnival/index.html?tag=result;title;0

1UP: Action http://www.1up.com/do/gameOverview?cId=3150533

Eye of Judgement is iffy I agree. Fall officially starts on September 23rd. August titles are Summer.

 There can be action adventure RPGs. Folklore has RPG elements written all over it. The fact you explore collect stuff, and do the basic follow character's life through the adventure. 

That's no different from the Legend of Zelda. 

Of course to me I don't even consider Fire Emblem an RPG. I consider it a strategy game.  To me RPGS need to be menu based for me to consider them RPGs... and not strategy games like Fire Emblem.