By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
naznatips on 03 September 2007
Edit Thread
Legend11 said:
naznatips said:

Personally, I think Peter Molyneux is a man with great vision, but an unfortunately big mouth. I didn't dislike Fable even though it was nothing it was promised to be, because I respected it as a very solid and well made action RPG. It was nothing revolutionary, and people who don't limit themselves to one console (not you) realize that there were many better RPGs made last generation, as well as many much more revolutionary ones. However, the game was fun, and that's what's important. I stand by my statement that it's stupid to believe anything said about this game until there is visual proof. I find it ironic that you can trust Peter Molyneux, who has a history of promising a bunch of crap that doesn't come true, but you didn't even believe Nibris existed until you saw a video of Raid over the River.


Have you actually watched any of his recent interviews? In them he no longer has a "big mouth" in fact he almost always states that he learned his lesson from Fable and will no longer talk about features or play up things that won't be in the game.

Oh and why do I trust Peter Molyneux over Nibris? Well Peter Molyneux is a legendary game designer in charge of a well known studio that has actually released games and that is owned and published by one of the biggest companies in the World. Nibris on the other hand we have NO idea who's working there (well besides the guy who's fanart they tried to pass off as concept art), have released NO games, and have NO publisher, hell we don't even know if they have an actual studio since we know next to NOTHING about them. They're a running joke at Neogaf and a lot of other message boards and gaming websites and you wonder why *I* don't take them seriously?

Also about the other games, you do realize that dispite the fact that he has had a few misses the majority of the time a person gets a good game (for fans of his work). But hey why don't we stop with the FUD being thrown around in this thread? Actually I tell you what, I'm willing to make some bets to see who's going to be right about this game.

Here's how sure I am that Fable 2 is going to be great and that Nibris is a joke, I'll take any of these bets:

I'll bet you that Fable 2 will get at least an 85% on Gamerankings.
I'll bet you that the gameplay trailer that Nibris promised for Sadness this year won't be released.
I'll bet you that Fable 2 will be released before Sadness.
I'll bet you that when March 2009 rolls around that Sadness will *still not* be released. Hell I'm nice, lets make that March 2010.

The winner gets to pick a new profile picture/avatar that the user must use for 6 months. So will you take any of those bets?


Actually, I have a lot more respect for Molyneux after the apology he gave for his promises in Fable that weren't true. Big mouth may not be the right words, more like "ambitious talker." He has trouble controling his ambitions and keeping them within the realms of possibility.

About people always getting a good game "for fans of his work:" that was my point. There are a lot of people who are not fans of his work. Although I have enjoyed some of his games, I'm certainly not creating a Molyneux fanclub anytime soon. I didn't say it's not right to be skeptical about Nibris. I wasn't sure they were making anything until I saw the video either. I just don't see how you can not be skeptical about anything said about this game given his history? I don't think he tries to lie to people, I just think his visions get out of control. Besides: Water effects better than Bioshock? You should at least be skeptical about that one.

Bet 1:

I agree with you...

Bet 2:

I agree with you... they don't have a publisher, isn't it unreasonable to expect it this year?

Bet 3:

I agree with you... see Bet 2

Bet 4:

I would accept this, but I don't see us remembering this in 2 and a half years.

Edit: why do you continue to believe I hate Fable? I told you it's my favorite Xbox game. Of course I expect Fable 2 to be good. I simply refuse to believe any promises made until I see them.