Reasonable on 17 January 2009
I really like Fallout 3, but it's too buggy and the main quest ends way to abruptly (hello DLC that removes it and adds more levels) for it to be GOTY for me.
GOTY for me means a great game, that's very polished in terms of stability, that innovates and stands out.
Fallout 3 is great, but it doesn't check the markers that make up my criteria.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
