Fumanchu on 13 January 2009
| dib8rman said: So, I'm *insert ad-hominem here* gotcha ;) The line you paraphrased is a logical arguement. >_> Lastly - mob mentality can be used as an excuse to free a group of people from a murder charge - it doesn't mean that murder is good, it just means that people are viewed as not within a self-controllable mental state when they commited to the act. That means; "Just because everyone jumps off a bridge doesn't mean you have to also." |
Yes, you are.
It is not a logical argument. Your logic is that there could only be two perspectives dealing in extremes. We either agree with his sentiments and like the PS3 -> better than => PC/360/Wii or we call out his contribute criteria. =/= logical argument.
There are many perspectives not just extreme prejudices. It's clear as day as to its intent.
I didn't skim through the pages of replies and look for similar comments to build up the courage to reiterate my own belief, which it so happens was actually shared by many others.
Can you please start debating the initial argument and not some "ad-hominem" arrogant philosophy that consists of "logical arguments" comprised of pre-ordained generalisations.
