I think if you go back to when the HD DVD came out for the 360, the same three reasons could have been thrown at that, no one asked for it, expensive, most people wont buy it so not profitable for gaming.
Really it is a case of 'add-on' of any description being pointless, if we look back at similar types of add-ons for previous systems, the general trend is public indifference.
So i think he is correct, probably a few more than 3 reasons if we are really honest. What i am really interested in is whether the next gen xbox will have it or whether they go for something completely new.







