Now that the dust has settled is GTA4 a good game or not ?

[disolitude]

Barozi said:

disolitude said:

oliminator1994 said:
I would call it a 7.5 out of 10

With San Andrea being a 9.5

And Vice city being a 9

In my books its as follows.

GTA3 - 9.9/10

GTA3:VC - 9.5/10

GTA:SA - 9/10

GTA4 - 8.5/10

And I have played them in that chronological order. If you've never played any of them, GTA4 is the best one by a mile.

I just find that they are not adding enough and keeping too much the same.

Finally someone who thinks GTA 3 is the best of all GTA games :D

I agree to all of your ratings.

 

Yeah, if one played them in the order they came out in, I don't see how they wouldn't put GTA3 as number 1. Like, adjusted for time and all, the first one is the most impressive by far. Rest have just added a new weapon here and there, new story and a reskin...