Now that the dust has settled is GTA4 a good game or not ?

[Wii_R2_Hardcore]

From what I understand, the improved the graphics and the phisics but cut a lot fun of things to do in the city. The more real it wasthe less fun it became. Over hyped and overrated. But not bad game. Just not as good as San Andreas or Vice City because HD graphics doesn´t make a game good.