4.5?? Dont' you give rankings like 4.5 to games that are completely broken and you basically can't have any fun?
ign 1up
Metroid 3 9.5 9
bug island 4 2
madden 08 8.5 4.5
m. strikers 8.3 7.5
boogie 4.5 3
alien synd. 5.5 4.5
the bigs 7.0 5.5
pokemon 5.0 4.5
transform 6.0 4.0
harry pott 7.8 8
RE4 9 8
ratatouile 7 5
big brain 7.6 6.5
mortal kom 7.8 6.5
papr mario 8.9 8.0
sims 2 7.2 5.0
MP8 5.2 5.5
wario ware 8.2 8.0
red steel 6.0 5.0
rayman 8.3 7.0
zelda 9.5 10
trauma c 8.0 6.5
only a few games on the entire list of like 40 games scored better at 1up then on IGN. This has been beat to death, but it's hard to ignore.
currently playing: Skyward Sword, Mario Sunshine, Xenoblade Chronicles X